The shawl-collared sweater is one of the most versatile pieces in a man’s wardrobe, yet it often polarises opinion. For some, it’s a classic symbol of effortless style, while others dismiss it as outdated or overly formal, and the truth lies somewhere in between. Whether you’re debating adding one to your collection or rediscovering a forgotten gem in your closet, this knitwear staple has strengths and challenges.
Then, there’s the practicality. Shawl-collared sweaters are usually made from heavy-duty materials like wool or cashmere, often featuring a ribbed weave for added warmth and durability. This thicker construction isn’t just about comfort but adds depth and texture to your outfit. On a chilly day, the extra weight feels like a cosy embrace, while the collar itself can be turned up to shield against the wind. The design also lends itself well to layering, allowing you to experiment with everything from lightweight turtlenecks to crisp Oxford shirts underneath.
First, the pros: a shawl-collared sweater offers a distinct aesthetic that balances casual and refined. The rolled, rounded collar is its signature feature, adding a touch of sophistication to even the most basic outfit. Unlike crewnecks or V-necks, the shawl collar creates a structured, almost tailored silhouette that elevates your look without needing a blazer or overcoat. Pair it with jeans and Chelsea boots for a brilliant casual vibe, or layer it over a button-down shirt with chinos for a more polished appearance. This versatility makes it an excellent choice for transitional weather and occasions where you want to appear put-together without being overly formal.
However, every piece of clothing has its drawbacks. Shawl-collared sweaters, while stylish, can sometimes veer into overly preppy territory if not styled thoughtfully. There’s a fine line between looking effortlessly cool and resembling a character from an old-school yacht club and to avoid this, it’s essential to choose modern fits and avoid overly bright or traditional colours unless they suit your style. For a contemporary touch, think of muted tones like charcoal, navy, or earthy browns.
Another challenge lies in the weight of the fabric; while the thickness is a blessing in colder months, it can feel cumbersome indoors or during mild weather, and it’s not the kind of sweater you’d grab for a breezy spring evening. Additionally, the dense weave and high-quality materials often mean shawl-collared sweaters come with a higher price tag, so investing in one can feel daunting, especially if you’re unsure how you’ll usually wear it. The solution? Look for timeless designs that won’t go out of style, ensuring your purchase remains relevant for years.
Finally, there’s the care factor. Many shawl-collared sweaters, particularly those made from cashmere or fine wool, require delicate handling. Dry cleaning or handwashing is often recommended, which can be a hassle if you’re used to low-maintenance knits. However, taking the time to care for it properly ensures it retains its shape, texture, and overall appeal.
Ultimately, the shawl-collared sweater is a worthwhile addition to any wardrobe when chosen and styled with intention. With its unique blend of warmth, style, and versatility, it’s a piece that transcends fleeting trends. While it may demand a bit more care and consideration, the payoff is a look that’s timelessly elegant and effortlessly cool.
View the original article here
